|
|
Rethinking
Rates
Econoday International
Perspectives 7/31/00
By Anne D. Picker, International Economist |
Strong
economic data give central bankers something to think about
There was a time not too long ago when strong
growth ignited a market rally. Not last week. The surprisingly strong
5.2 percent jump in U.S. second-quarter GDP led to a sell off on Friday
that spared no one. The Asian markets had already closed, but dropped
earlier in reaction to the Nasdaq's troubles o/n Thursday. In Japan
the Nikkei reacted negatively to mixed domestic economic news. Even
the high flying Toronto Stock Exchange Composite suffered its lumps,
on Thursday because of a canceled merger and on Friday because of U.S.
GDP. Exuberant U.S. growth translates to higher interest rate concerns
in Canada, which in turn impacts equities and the Canadian dollar. The
table below shows last week's carnage.
Aside from important economic
data, earnings reports and warnings of slower future profit growth burdened
the markets. Because of the weighting mechanisms used to calculate the
indexes, strong movements in a few stocks frequently have a disproportionate
impact. This was undoubtedly the case last week in Toronto and Frankfurt.
What was bad for the equity markets, however, was good for the dollar.
The dollar rose against most of the major currencies including the euro
and yen.
Selected
World Stock Market Indexes |
|
Index
|
July
28
|
July
21
|
Percent
Change
|
Asia |
|
|
|
|
Australia |
All Ordinaries
|
3219
|
3290
|
-2.16
|
Japan |
Nikkei 225
|
15839
|
16811
|
-5.79
|
Hong Kong |
Hang Seng
|
17184
|
17921
|
-4.11
|
S. Korea |
Kospi
|
693
|
783
|
-11.55
|
Singapore |
Sing. Strait
|
2039
|
2127
|
-4.12
|
|
|
|
|
|
Europe |
|
|
|
|
Britain |
FTSE 100
|
6336
|
6378
|
-0.67
|
France |
CAC
|
6416
|
6464
|
-0.75
|
Germany |
DAX
|
7128
|
7373
|
-3.32
|
|
|
|
|
|
North
America |
|
|
|
|
United States |
Dow
|
10511
|
10734
|
-2.07
|
|
Nasdaq
|
3663
|
4094
|
-10.54
|
Canada |
TSE Composite
|
10343
|
10842
|
-4.60
|
Mexico |
Bolsa
|
6344
|
6719
|
-5.58
|
|
|
|
|
|
Britain
and Europe
The London FTSE 100 and the Paris
CAC survived the week with the
least damage. Once again London trading was lackluster. The markets
would fight for small gains in the morning, only to give way to negative
sentiment emanating from U.S. markets - and particularly the Nasdaq
- in the afternoon. Bulls and bears resorted to standard market comments
such as "what goes up must come down" (bears) or "there is an underlying
appetite for equities" (bulls). The Bank of England Monetary Policy
Committee meeting slated for Wednesday and Thursday this week added
to investors' angst given the stronger than expected numbers even though
analysts are expecting rates to stay the same. The London markets also
had to contend with the deluge of earnings reports. The FTSE 100 fell
42.7 points on the week or 0.67 percent to end the week at 6335.70.
The Frankfurt DAX
continues to be affected by the offs and ons in merger activity. Another
banking merger was canceled in Germany, where such combinations seem
troublesome, while a telecommunications merger was proposed. And as
data showing higher inflation were released (see Indicator scoreboard
below), new worries surfaced about interest rates. It had been assumed
that the European Central Bank would wait until after their August vacation
to raise rates, but now market players weren't so sure. Yet according
to most, the odds hold that the ECB will leave rates unchanged at their
Thursday meeting. The DAX closed down 244.96 points or 3.32 percent
at 7128.30.
The Paris CAC
slid on earnings reports and the Concorde plane crash. However, the
economic reports from France continue to be positive. As in Frankfurt,
the upcoming ECB meeting could distract Paris, although nothing is expected
to happen. The CAC was down 48.4 points or 0.75 percent to end the week
at 6415.72. Both the CAC and DAX are slightly above their 1999 year
end levels while the FTSE continues to be lower.
Asia
Asian markets caught cold as the Nasdaq plummeted. In South Korea, the
fall in dynamic random access memory chip prices raised concerns about
slowing growth in the industry and the Kospi plummeted. Most analysts
expected chip prices to continue rising. However, in Japan no sector
was immune from profit taking and selling.
The Nikkei
declined for a variety of reasons. Investors continue to be concerned
about the economy following recent high profile bankruptcies. As revealed
by the new economic data (see indicator scoreboard below) the nature
of the economic recovery has been uneven at best. This clouds the question
of whether the Bank of Japan will raise interest rates from near zero
as they keep threatening to do. The Nikkei ended the week under the
psychologically important 16,000 level at 15,838.57, down 972.92 points
or 5.79 percent.
In other markets, the Hong
Kong Hang Seng dropped 726.93 points
or 4.11 percent to close out the week at 17,183.93. The South Korean
Kospi fell 90.41 points or a sharp
11.55 percent to end the week below the 700 level at 692.65. Only the
Hang Seng and the Australian all ordinaries are above 1999 year end
levels.
Currencies
The euro fell against the dollar
amid speculation investors will continue to funnel money to U.S. assets,
boosting demand for dollars. The euro continues to be pressured despite
positive economic data. The data implied that the European Central Bank
would have to raise interest rates again sooner rather then later. The
ECB's key refinancing rate of 4.25 percent compares with 6.5 percent
in the United States. Higher rates could boost the euro by narrowing
the rate advantage dollar deposits offer. However, there is concern
that if interest rates are increased, it will crimp growth and hurt
the currency. When EMU data point to higher rates, the market interprets
that as negative for growth and often the euro falls. There is still
a voracious appetite for U.S. assets as various merger proposals emerge
for U.S. companies.
The euro was particularly
pressured on Thursday and Friday by strong data that showed the U.S.
is still growing faster than expected. Market players had decided that
the growth gap between the United States and the European Monetary Union
was closing making Europe more attractive for investors. Last week's
data put at least a temporary end to that speculation and once again
raises the specter of higher U.S. interest rates on August 22. This
would also put an end to expectations of a narrower interest rate spread
between the EMU and the U.S.
The yen
hovered near a nine week low against the dollar amid concern a series
of Japanese corporate bankruptcies are a sign the economic recovery
may stall. That could further sap demand for Japanese stocks and the
currency needed to buy them. Japanese bankruptcies rose more than 20
percent in June when compared with a year earlier, This was the eighth
straight increase in the bankruptcy rate, and more companies are expected
to fail in coming months. And adding to investors' uncertainly, rating
agency Moody's Investors Service has had Japan's credit under review
for a possible downgrade since February.
The verdict on the Japanese
expansion continues to be mixed (see indicator scoreboard). The data
highlights the fact that the U.S. economy is still strong and brings
into relief the contrast with the Japanese economy, which is still iffy
at best.
Indicator
scoreboard
EMU - May industrial
production rose 0.8 percent on the month and 7.2 percent
when compared with last year. Industrial output rose in all sub-components
on the month. The largest increase was in durable consumer goods, up
1.4 percent, followed by intermediate goods (1.2 percent), non-durable
consumer goods (0.6 percent) and capital goods (0.4 percent).
June M3
money supply and private sector credit growth decelerated
for the second straight month. June seasonally adjusted M3 contracted
0.3 percent - only the second time a contraction has occurred since
the ECB began to publish this statistic. When compared with last year,
M3 rose 5.4 percent in June, lower than the unrevised 5.9 percent in
May. The three month (April to June) moving average of 12 month rates
fell to 6.0 percent from 6.4 percent in the March to May period. The
three-month moving average, which is used by the ECB as one of its main
monetary policy guides, is 150 basis above the ECB's 4.5 percent monetary
growth reference value.
Germany
- May revised seasonally and price adjusted industrial
production rose 2.8 percent on the month, up from the 2.2
percent increase originally reported. Manufacturing output rose a revised
2.6 percent on the month mainly due to strong increases in basic goods.
Capital goods production increased 2.3 percent. In west Germany, output
rose a revised 2.7 percent on the month, and in the east, output was
revised up to 2.4 percent.
June import
prices rose 0.1 percent on the month and 11.5 percent on
the year. The increase was caused mostly by a rise in oil prices, offset
slightly by declining capital goods prices. Import prices excluding
oil products fell 0.4 percent but were up 6.2 percent on the year. Seasonally
adjusted import prices rose 0.4 percent in June and were 11.5 percent
above last year. June seasonally adjusted export prices remained unchanged
but climbed 3.6 percent on the year, after rising 0.7 percent on the
month and 3.8 percent on the year in May.
June producer
prices climbed 0.3 percent and 2.9 percent when compared
with last year. Surging oil prices were again the driving force behind
the overall rise in PPI. They jumped 4.7 percent on the month and 34.6
percent when compared with last year. Excluding oil products, producer
prices rose 0.2 percent on the month and by only 1.7 percent on the
year. Seasonally adjusted PPI rose by 0.4 percent on the month and by
3.1 percent when compared with last year. Excluding energy, the PPI
rose 0.1 percent on the month and 2.0 percent on the year.
July preliminary seasonally
adjusted consumer prices for the
six months to July rose at an annualized rate of 1.9 percent. Seasonally
adjusted prices were up 0.1 percent on the month and up 1.8 percent
on the year, compared to the unadjusted rise of 0.4 percent on the month
and annual increase of 1.8 percent.
France
-June seasonally adjusted unemployment rate
fell by 0.2 percent to 9.6 percent, according to the ILO definition,
which excludes job seekers who did any work during the month.
Italy
- April employment in large industrial
firms contracted by 2.3 percent when compared with last year, but the
number of large firm service sector jobs rose 0.1 percent. The data
confirms the long running trend in which most new employment is being
created among small and medium sized service sector companies, while
large industrial firms, in particular, are steadily shedding jobs.
June non-EU merchandise trade
surplus was L210 billion after a deficit in May of L434 billion.
Non-EU imports were up 40.8 percent when compared with last year while
exports rose by 14.6 percent. High oil and commodities imports prices
had eaten into the surplus. The May trade deficit with its EU trading
partners was L813 billion (EU trade data are reported a month behind
that for non-EU trade). Exports to the EU rose 20.2 percent from May
1999 and imports were up 22.9 percent. May world trade deficit stood
at L1.246 trillion, with imports rising 37.8 percent when compared with
last year and exports were up 25.7 percent.
Britain
- June merchandise trade deficit
with countries outside the European Union widened in June as strong
growth in the value of imports continued to out pace that of exports.
The non-EU deficit widened to Stg2.089 billion in June from Stg1.798
billion in the previous month. Exports to non-EU countries were up 2.0
percent while imports jumped 5.0 percent. The May global goods deficit
narrowed slightly to Stg2.539 billion compared with Stg2.631 billion
in the previous month.
July business
confidence in the manufacturing sector fell at the fastest
rate since January last year. Order books also showed further deterioration
according to the quarterly industrial trends survey of the Confederation
of British Industry. The survey shows that the business confidence balance
fell to -10 percent in July from -2 percent in April. Manufacturers'
optimism about their export prospects also weakened sharply.
Asia
Japan - June merchandise trade surplus
rose 3.0 percent on the year. Exports were up 9.8 percent while imports
rose 12.5 percent. The trade surplus with the United States fell 1.9
percent. Exports rose 1.5 percent while imports rose 5.2 percent. Japan's
trade surplus rose for the first time in three months, raising fears
about the strength of its economic recovery. The declining surplus has
been seen as a sign that domestic demand in Japan is finally picking
up after years of recession, with consumers buying more imported goods.
June retail
sales fell 1.1 percent on the year while large stores retail
sales fell 2.2 percent and were down 4.4 percent when adjusted for store
closings and new stores. Total sales were up 0.7 percent on the year
while wholesale sales rose 1.2 percent.
June seasonally adjusted unemployment
rate rose to 4.7 percent from 4.6 percent in May. The number
of employed decreased by 0.2 percent while the number of unemployed
fell 2.4 percent on the year. The labor force participation rate was
63.0 percent. The number of workers employed by small businesses continued
to fall, dropping by 0.6 percent on the year. But those employed by
large companies (those companies employing more than 500 people) climbed
1.9 percent, gaining for the ninth straight month.
June spending
by wage earners was down 2.6 percent in real terms from a
year earlier, suggesting that improvement in the corporate sector has
yet to spark a recovery in consumption. The propensity for wage earners
to consume, a ratio which measures the amount of disposable income that
went to household spending, edged up to 73.2 percent from 72.9 percent
in May on a seasonally adjusted nominal basis.
July Tokyo consumer
price index was down 0.2 percent on the month and down 0.9
percent on the previous year. In all of Japan the June CPI fell 0.3
percent and was down 0.7 percent on the previous year.
June seasonally adjusted industrial
production rose 1.7 percent and jumped 7.0 percent when compared
with last year. Shipments rose 2.5 percent on the month and 7.5 percent
on the year while inventories were down 0.1 percent on the month and
down 0.8 percent on the year.
Hong
Kong - June consumer prices
dropped 4.5 percent when compared with last year. June's fall was the
20th straight monthly decline, and kept pace with the drop in May
Australia
- Second quarter consumer price index
rose 0.8 percent and 3.2 percent when compared with a year earlier.
Inflation breached the Reserve Bank's 2 to 3 percent target band for
the first time since June 1996. The data confirms rising inflationary
pressures, largely stemming from a weaker Australian dollar, higher
oil prices, and continuing strong growth.
Americas
Canada
- June industrial product prices
(IPPI) were unchanged but were up 5.5 percent when compared with June
1999. A 4.8 percent increase in petroleum and coal products prices was
offset by declines in prices for other industrial goods. When compared
with last year, roughly half of June's rise was the result of a 52.0
percent increase in prices for petroleum and coal products. If the impact
of petroleum and coal product prices were excluded, June's advance in
industrial product prices would have been 2.7 percent instead of 5.5
percent.
June raw
materials prices rose 2.1 percent and 28.3 percent when compared
to last year primarily because of higher prices for mineral fuels. If
mineral fuels were excluded, the year over year increase in the RMPI
would have been only 6.3 percent instead of 28.3 percent. On a month
to month basis, the index would have declined 1.8 percent instead of
increasing 2.1 percent.
BOTTOM
LINE
News that U.S. gross domestic product rose much higher than expected
ignited doubts about whether the economy has slowed to the more sustainable
pace that many market analysts had assumed. This naturally led to anxieties
over a possible August 22 interest rate increase. Much of the increase
in GDP was where you would want to see it - in productivity enhancing
investment and not consumer expenditures. But there will be a lot of
new data on inflation and the labor market available before August 22.
Stay tuned.
Looking
Ahead: June 26 to June 30, 2000
|
Central
Bank Activities |
|
|
August 2, 3 |
Britain |
Bank of England Monetary
Policy Committee Meeting |
August 3 |
EMU |
European Central Bank
Monetary Policy Committee Meeting |
|
|
|
The following indicators
will be released this week... |
Europe |
|
|
July 31 |
EMU |
Merchandise Trade (May) |
|
France |
Producer Price Index (June) |
|
Italy |
Producer Price Index (June) |
|
|
Britain Nationwide Housing
Price Index (July) |
August 1 |
EMU |
Unemployment (June) |
|
|
EMU Reuters PMI (July) |
|
Germany |
BME/Reuters PMI (July) |
|
Italy |
Reuters/ADACI PMI (July) |
|
|
Industrial Sales and Orders
(May) |
|
France |
CDAF-Reuters PMI Index
(July) |
|
Britain |
PMI Manufacturing Survey
(July) |
|
Germany |
Wholesale Sales (June) |
August 2 |
EMU |
Retail Sales (May) |
August 4 |
EMU |
Producer Price Index (June) |
|
EU |
Business/Consumer Survey
(June) |
Asia |
|
|
July 31 |
Australia |
Merchandise Trade (June) |
August 2 |
Australia |
Retail Sales (June) |
|
|
|
Americas |
|
|
July 31 |
Canada |
Gross Domestic Product
at Factor Cost (May) |
August 4 |
Canada |
Unemployment Rate (July) |
Release dates are subject
to change.
For U.S. data releases, see this week's Simply Economics.
|