![](ipheader.gif) |
![](ip_charts/ip_icon.gif) |
The
rate debate
Econoday
International Perspectives 6/12/00
By Anne D. Picker, International Economist
|
Will
the ECB's rate hike stymie EMU's economic growth?
Overseas markets treaded water
trying to catch their collective breath after the phenomenal increases
of the preceding week. British and European investors were awaiting
their respective central banks' decisions on interest rates. Asian markets
waited with great anticipation for first quarter Japanese gross domestic
product - they wanted to see if the economy had turned itself around
and was growing again. After the previous week's gains in the major
indexes, naturally there was some profit taking as well.
At week's end a great debate
was shaping up, whether the European Central Bank had raised rates more
than the European economies can bear. The 50 basis point jump shocked
the markets. And certainly the economic performance numbers will be
scrutinized even closer. Investors will be watching for any signs of
weakness. Meanwhile, the jury is still out...
Selected
World Stock Market Indexes |
|
Index |
June
9 |
June
2 |
Percent
Change |
Asia |
|
|
|
|
Australia |
All Ordinaries |
3102 |
3096 |
0.18 |
Japan |
Nikkei 225 |
16862 |
16800 |
0.37 |
Hong Kong |
Hang Seng |
16120 |
15284 |
5.47 |
S. Korea |
Kospi |
836 |
761 |
9.95 |
Singapore |
Sing. Strait |
2043 |
1910 |
6.92 |
|
|
|
|
|
Europe |
|
|
|
|
Britain |
FTSE 100 |
6444 |
6626 |
-2.76 |
France |
CAC |
6549 |
6674 |
-1.87 |
Germany |
DAX |
7255 |
7435 |
-2.48 |
|
|
|
|
|
North
America |
|
|
|
|
United States |
Dow |
10614 |
10795 |
-1.67 |
|
Nasdaq |
3875 |
3813 |
1.61 |
Canada |
TSE Composite |
9729 |
9748 |
-0.19 |
Mexico |
Bolsa |
6399 |
6627 |
-3.45 |
|
|
|
|
|
The South Korean and Hong
Kong markets were closed on Tuesday. |
Britain and Europe
Equity markets were sluggish
after their amazing performance the week before. On the week's agenda
was the Bank of England's and the European Central Bank's policy meetings
to determine interest rate levels. Trading was dull as investors vacillated
between new and old economy stocks and took some profits. Investors
were also looking to secure their positions prior to the bank meetings.
The trend in interest rates in Britain, the EMU and the United States
obviously plays a big part in determining market performance.
In Britain, the FTSE
100 seemed to run out of steam
after its superlative performance in the prior week. A dose of profit
taking was behind the decline in London's benchmark index. Low volume
indicated that institutions were holding back until after the Bank of
England's interest rate decision on Wednesday. As expected, the bank's
monetary policy committee left interest rates on hold at 6 percent.
But the FTSE 100 faltered on news of a surprise rise in European interest
rates. At week's end, the FTSE 100 stood at 6443.8, down 182.6 points
or 2.76 percent.
News that the European Central
Bank had lifted European Monetary Union interest rates by 50 basis points
came as a considerable shock to European markets, which had priced in
a 25 basis points rise. Both the Paris CAC and Frankfurt DAX lost ground
with the CAC
ending the week at 6549.05, down 124.47 points or 1.87 percent while
the DAX lost
184.42 points or 2.48 percent to close at 7254.53.
Asia
Asian shares put in a mixed performance
with local factors having the biggest impact. Hong Kong Hang
Seng leaped 836 points or 5.47
percent as investors cheered signs that U.S. growth might be slowing
down making further Federal Reserve rate hikes unnecessary. This boosted
shares of the important rate-dependent property sector. Hong Kong, with
its currency linked to the U.S. dollar, must adjust its interest rates
accordingly when the Fed acts. The Hang Seng closed above 16,000 at
16,120.26.
The Nikkei
225 struggled to remain about even
on the week. Anxiety about first quarter gross domestic product contributed
to the downside. Gross domestic product rose by 2.4 per cent on the
quarter against predictions of a 2.8 per cent rise. A market pundit
noted that this was the fastest growth since the last leap quarter in
1996, which adds an extra day to the quarter. The Nikkei remains nervous
about the insurance company failures of recent weeks along with the
political uncertainty from the June 25th election. The Nikkei
225 ended the week at 16,861.91, up 61.85 points or 0.37 percent.
The South Korean Kospi
outperformed the markets tracked
here, jumping 9.95 percent or 75.71 points, to end the week at 826.40.
Stocks rose on optimism that deregulation of the financial industry
will accelerate following a report of a major bank merger. Foreign demand
was strong. Construction shares also were in favor on expectations that
next week's historic inter-Korean summit would help boost business for
construction companies.
Currencies
Currency transactions were dominated
by the expectation of a 25 basis point European Central Bank interest
rate increase. However, there was a catch - the 25 basis point increase
turned out to be a 50 basis point increase and shocked the markets.
The euro
increased in value against the major currencies building up to Thursday's
rate increase, which was expected to narrow the spread between EMU rates
and those in the United States and Britain. A shrinking rate gap would
make euro deposits more attractive, prompting investors to shift more
funds to euros. The currency soared initially when the 50 basis point
interest rate increase was announced. However, it slithered downward
as market players began to have second thoughts and became worried about
the rate increase's impact on economic growth.
The euro had gained in
the last two weeks as upbeat economic reports reinforced expectations
of an ECB rate increase. However, after the initial euphoria, the market
started to worry this might stifle the upswing in some of the member
countries and by week's end the euro had fallen. Higher borrowing costs
could hurt company profits, which would slow economic expansion and
business investment. Now the debate is beginning in earnest. Investors
are wondering if the ECB is being overly aggressive with its monetary
tightening. Although European economies are accelerating, they may not
be able to withstand an aggressive approach to interest rates.
The yen
rose in the early part of the week as a rebound in Japanese stocks sparked
optimism that demand for shares would bolster the currency and on expectations
of a strong gross domestic product report on Friday. Tokyo markets rose
sending the Nikkei 225 stock index up and generating demand from international
investors for yen to buy shares. This however, was short lived and the
Nikkei oozed down taking the yen with it.
The yen was also helped
by a capital spending report that bolstered optimism for Japan's illusive
recovery. That in turn sparked speculation that the Bank of Japan may
move away from its current zero interest rate policy and raise rates.
This could persuade Japanese investors to keep more money at home.
But the yen fell, especially
after GDP was reported to have grown more slowly than expected. This
dashed hopes that the Bank of Japan would be able to abandon its zero
interest rate policy and raise Japanese interest rates from near zero
percent.
Central
Bank Activities
The Bank
of England's Monetary Policy Committee
announced after its regular monthly rate setting meeting that it would
leave its policy making refinance rate unchanged at 6.00 percent, 50
basis points below that of the Federal Reserve.
The European
Central Bank surprised the markets
and raised its policy making refinance rate 50 basis points to 4.25
percent. The markets had expected a 25 basis point increase. The ECB
last raised its rates on April 27th when it hiked the rate
by 25 basis points to 3.75 percent. The refinancing rate is the interest
the ECB charges commercial banks for buying back short term securities
when banks need cash.
The ECB also raised two
other rates, which form the floor and ceiling for the money market,
by 50 basis points. The overnight deposit rate was increased to 3.25
percent and the marginal lending rate was raised to 5.25 percent. The
overnight rate is the interest paid by the ECB to banks when local banks
deposit excess money with the central bank. The marginal lending rate
is interest paid by banks to the ECB, when they need quick emergency
loans.
The move has been controversial,
because analysts are concerned that the rate hike might be too strong
for the newly growing economies to absorb.
Indicator
scoreboard
EMU
- The April seasonally adjusted unemployment
rate fell to 9.2 percent. In addition,
the March unemployment rate was revised down to 9.3 percent from 9.4
percent. The unemployment rate is at its lowest level since July 1992.
The April decline was due in large part to drops in France and Spain.
The French unemployment rate declined to 10.0 percent in April from
10.2 percent in March, while Spain's rate fell to 14.1 percent in April
from 14.4 percent in March.
The May European Commission's
economic sentiment
index for the 11 EMU states was
steady for the third month in succession, although both consumer and
industrial sentiment improved in the reporting month. The overall index
stood at 104.0, unchanged from the unrevised readings in April and in
March. A national breakdown of the latest data shows that overall economic
sentiment rose in four of the 11 EU countries - Germany, France, Portugal
and Finland - and fell in four - Spain, Ireland, Italy and Austria.
April industrial
producer prices, excluding construction,
rose 0.1 percent on the month and 5.7 percent on the year after having
increased a revised 0.7 percent on the month and 6.2 percent on the
year in March. The main factor behind April's strong overall PPI jump
was a 0.4 percent monthly and 9.8 percent annual increase in intermediate
goods prices. This category contains prices for oil and other commodities,
which have been strongly affected by the weak euro.
First quarter preliminary
gross domestic product
rose 0.7 percent on the quarter and 3.2 percent on the year. First quarter
growth was led by a sharp rise in investment as well as stronger government
spending. However, private consumption was flat. The net exports were
2.1 percent of GDP. Gross fixed capital formation jumped 2.1 percent.
First quarter domestic demand rose 0.7 percent after a 0.6 percent rise
in the previous quarter.
Germany
- April seasonally adjusted manufacturing
orders increased 2.5 percent from
the previous month as a sharp rise in domestic demand offset a slight
decline in foreign orders. Domestic orders were up 4.6 percent on the
month, while foreign orders declined 0.5 percent. April east German
manufacturing orders surged 12.7 percent mainly due to increased capital
goods orders while west German orders rose 1.6 percent.
April pan-German industrial
production rose 1.5 percent. The
rise was led by a 1.8 percent gain in manufacturing production. In west
Germany, April output rose 1.5 percent while in the east, output was
up 3.5 percent on the month.
May seasonally adjusted pan-German
unemployment rate
was steady at 9.6 percent in May. The rate in the west declined to 7.7
percent from 7.8 percent, while that in the east was unchanged at 17.3
percent.
Britain
- May Halifax house
prices fell a seasonally adjusted
0.4 percent on the month but rose 11.2 percent when compared with last
year. The annual rate slowed from 14.2 percent in April. This is the
third slight fall in the monthly rate in the past four months. The Halifax
said the slowdown in house price growth appears largely to be in response
to four mortgage interest rate increases since last September and the
abolition of mortgage interest tax relief in April.
Total housing
starts in the three months to April
fell a seasonally adjusted 3 percent compared with the previous quarter
and fell 3 percent on the year. Total completions in February to April
rose 2 percent on the previous quarter and 2 percent on the year earlier.
April industrial
output rose 0.8 percent and was
up 2.2 percent when compared with last year because cold weather boosted
demand for electricity and gas. March data were also revised up, with
industrial output increasing by 0.8 percent and by 1.5 percent when
compared with last year. April manufacturing output fell by 0.2 percent
on the month but was still up 1.6 percent on the year. March manufacturing
output climbed 0.6 percent on the month and 1.7 percent when compared
with last year.
Asia
Japan
- First quarter real gross
domestic product rose 2.4 percent
on the quarter and 10 percent on an annualized basis. This follows two
consecutive quarters of declines. Fourth quarter GDP was revised down
to -1.6 percent from a decline of 1.4 percent announced previously.
For the fiscal year 1999 (ending March 31, 2000) GDP rose 0.5 percent,
below the government's 0.6 percent target. First quarter private consumption
rose 1.8 percent. Private investment in housing was up 6.6 percent and
investment in equipment and facilities rose 4.2 percent. Government
expenditures were up 0.8 percent on the quarter while public investment
was down 7.5 percent.
First quarter business
investment rose 3.3 percent when
compared with last year, the first gain in nine quarters. Capital spending
in the manufacturing sector, however, dropped 6.1 percent, declining
for the seventh consecutive quarter.
First quarter corporate
pretax profits for all industries
jumped 38.7 percent from a year earlier, following a 41.8 percent rise
in the previous quarter. Overall sales rose 2.6 percent during the period,
after registering a 2.2 percent gain in the previous quarter.
May domestic wholesale
prices rose 0.1 percent and were
up 0.3 percent when compared with last year. Prices of non-ferrous metals
led the increase while petroleum and coal products and machinery decreased.
May export price
index decreased 0.3 percent on
the month in terms of contract currencies but was up 1.3 percent in
yen terms but down 7.6 percent on the year in terms of the yen. May
import price index
was down 1.0 percent in terms of contract currencies but rose 1.0 percent
in yen terms and was up 0.8 percent from the previous year in yen terms.
April key private sector
machinery orders
received by Japanese manufacturers fell a seasonally adjusted 1.1 percent.
The key orders are viewed as a leading indicator of corporate capital
investment six to nine months ahead. Total orders fell 1.9 percent from
the previous month, seasonally adjusted, while private sector orders
rose 4.7 percent. Manufacturing machine orders rose 9.3 percent on the
month.
Americas
Canada
- First quarter industry capacity
utilization soared to 87.6 percent,
surpassing the peak of the 1987-1988 economic expansion (86.8 percent).
The strength of surging exports and robust domestic demand pushed utilization
up for a sixth straight quarter, reaching a level not seen since the
mid-1960s. Manufacturing followed by construction contributed the most
to the increase in industrial production and resulting rise in first
quarter capacity utilization. Manufacturers boosted their rate of capacity
utilization by 0.7 percentage points, bringing the level to 87.9 percent,
1.0 percentage points shy of the 1974 historical peak. This marked the
fourth consecutive quarterly increase. Thirteen of the 22 manufacturing
industry groups (accounting for almost two-thirds of total factory output)
raised their rates.
May unemployment
rate dropped 0.2 percentage points
to 6.6 percent, the lowest since March 1976. Employment rose an estimated
42,000. When compared with last year, the number of jobs has risen 2.8
percent. All of the employment gain was in the private sector, where
the estimated number of employees increased by 32,000 and the number
of self-employed rose by 30,000. Job gains among private sector employees
are up 4.2 percent from May 1999, continuing an upward trend that began
about three years ago.
BOTTOM LINE
Focus on central bank activities
continues this week. First the Bank of Japan monetary policy committee
meets on Monday, followed later in the week by the Bank's monthly report.
The Bank of Japan has been looking for a positive sign to end their
extraordinary zero interest rate policy. Unfortunately, last week's
GDP data did not give it to them. Stable signs of growth still elude
the policy makers.
In Europe, debate whether
the 50 basis point interest rate increase was appropriate will continue.
Investors will be looking more closely for fault lines in new economic
data.
With the other major central
bank meetings over, the markets will focus with full intensity on the
United States. The countdown to the Federal Open Market Committee Meeting
will begin in earnest with the release of the Federal Reserve's Beige
Book on Wednesday. Since the weak employment report on June 2nd,
investors' moods have vacillated between optimism that the Fed will
not have to raise interest rates anymore to the prospect that more rate
increases are on the horizon.
Looking
Ahead: June 12 to June 16, 2000
|
Central
Bank Activities |
June 12 |
Japan |
Bank of Japan Monetary
Policy Board Meeting |
June 14 |
Japan |
Bank of Japan Monthly
Economic Report |
June 15 |
Japan |
Bank of Japan Monetary
Policy Board Minutes of April 27 meeting |
June 14 |
U.S. |
Federal Reserve Beige
Book |
|
|
|
The following indicators
will be released this week... |
|
|
|
Europe |
|
|
June 12 |
Britain |
Producer Price Index (May) |
June 13 |
Britain |
Retail Price Index (May) |
|
Germany |
Merchandise Trade (April) |
June 14 |
Britain |
Labor Market (May) |
|
|
Average Earnings (April) |
|
Germany |
Consumer Price Index (May) |
|
France |
Consumer Price Index (May) |
June 15 |
Britain |
Retail Sales (May) |
|
Germany |
Wholesale Price Index
(May) |
|
|
Retail Sales (April) |
|
Italy |
Industrial Production
(April) |
June 16 |
France |
Merchandise Trade (April) |
|
|
|
Asia |
|
|
June 12 |
Japan |
Merchandise Trade (April) |
June 13 |
Japan |
Revised Industrial Output
(April) |
|
Hong Kong |
Retail Sales (April) |
June 14 |
Australia |
Gross Domestic Product
(Q1, 2000) |
|
|
|
Americas |
|
|
June 15 |
Canada |
Manufacturing Survey (April) |
June 16 |
Canada |
Consumer Price Index (May) |
|
|
|
Release dates are subject
to change. |
For U.S. data releases,
see this week's Simply Economics. |
|