<%@ Language=VBScript %> <% Response.Write(cszCSS) %> Detailed Report
Today's
Calendar
 |  Simply
Economics
 |  International
Perspective
 |  Resource
Center
1999 Articles

International Perspectives - November 22, 1999
Anne D. Picker
International Economist, Econoday

Interest Rates and Oil Prices Revisited

Central Banks were busy last week...
Several central banks issued minutes of policy meetings and reports last week. One bank - the Bank of Canada - acted in response to the Federal Reserve's 25 basis point increase in the federal funds rate with an increase of 25 basis points to its bank rate. Now, with the exception of Japan, all of the G7 countries have raised interest rates. The European Central Bank and the Bank of England tightened on November 4th. Others that have increased rates include Sweden, Australia, Denmark and New Zealand.

Bank of Canada
The Bank of Canada today raised its Bank Rate by 25 basis points to five percent. The action followed the increase by U.S. Federal Reserve to raise its target level for the federal funds rate to 5.5 percent. The Bank of Canada's action will keep a 50 basis point spread between the countries' base lending rates. A larger spread was deemed detrimental to the Canadian dollar. The rate increase is the first since August 27, 1998, when the central bank intervened to stem a sliding dollar by lifting its benchmark lending rate a full percentage point to 6 percent. Since then, the central bank cut rates five times by a quarter percentage point each time.

The Bank of Canada highlighted several reasons to justify the increase in borrowing costs. The country's unemployment rate was at a nine year low 7.2 percent in October, while the trade surplus is at a three year high and gross domestic product rose by a greater than expected 0.7 percent in August. The central bank also pointed to robust U.S. economic growth and demand, which has a strong positive influence on Canadian growth prospects.

The Bank's action is designed to keep inflation well within the one to three per cent inflation target range set by the Bank. In this way monetary policy continues to support a sustainable rate of growth in output and employment in Canada.

Bank of England
The minutes showed the Monetary Policy Committee voted 8-1 for a 25 basis point rate increase at its last meeting. The Committee agreed that the current level of domestic demand growth is unsustainable for achieving the inflation target in the medium term even thought it admitted that uncertainty about the short-term relationship between output and inflation has intensified.

Bank of Japan
The Bank of Japan's Monetary Policy Board voted 7-1 in favor of expanding market operations at their October 13 meeting, saying that more operational tools would give the BOJ greater flexibility and increase market confidence in the bank's ability to ensure adequate liquidity. Several Monetary Policy Board members think that the economic and financial situation has improved. However, they also felt that there had been no significant change to the economic outlook from the previous meeting, and downward pressure on prices persisted.

The Bank of Japan's November report said that industrial output is up but wages and demand remain weak and the economy is being dragged slowly back to health by growing demand for its products from bullish Asian neighbors. But the BoJ said had been little sign of a rise in consumer spending, or a drop in unemployment. Exports remain the driving force behind the more positive outlook. The BoJ said the Japanese economy was far from a full scale recovery, citing the weak momentum in private demand.

Oil - a progress report...
With an Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) meeting scheduled for this weekend in Vienna, a progress report on oil prices is in order. At the meeting, the world's major oil producing countries will discuss plans to extend their production cuts beyond March 2000.

The world's economies always have been sensitive to the supply and price of commodities, especially oil. Prices for oil rise for two reasons - demand is rising and OPEC producers are limiting supply. World growth has become more vigorous and more oil is being demanded for factories and businesses, bidding up the price of energy. At the same time, OPEC has, for the first time in many years, been able to enforce production quotas on its members. This has reduced bloated inventories and decreased the supply available. The net result has been higher prices. The oil glut is shrinking and some analysts are forecasting continued inventory erosion now that the heating season is here.

Although OPEC appears set to adopt a status quo approach to quotas at this meeting, recent surveys suggest that some producers began to edge up production last month. However, a rapid reversal is always possible in a market that depends on the resolution of a few oil ministers to avoid temptation. As the price rises, the pressure to push up earnings by producing more oil becomes ever higher. However, the severe economic difficulties of many oil producing countries, such as Nigeria and Venezuela, appear to make discipline more likely. And although OPEC countries produce only about 40 per cent of the world's oil at present, they have nearly three-quarters of reserves.

Oil prices rallied as OPEC members led efforts to reduce output by five million barrels a day, or about seven percent of total supply. The cuts were intended to eliminate surpluses. Observers have said that they have been surprised by the unity shown this year by OPEC, in contrast to previous attempts at production cuts, which were often undermined by cheating. But they suggested that they would be more difficult now to prevent some heavily indebted countries from cashing in on the higher oil price. The compliance of OPEC producers with output ceilings has not dropped as much as some believed as the September compliance level has been revised up to 91 percent from 86 percent and October compliance is down to 87 percent.

The rise in oil prices has boosted the stock of the world's leading oil companies. In the period after 1985, when OPEC collapsed and oil prices fluctuated between about $15 and $20, the big oil companies made spectacular efficiency gains. The cost of finding, developing and operating a new source of oil has fallen to only about $6 per barrel, less than half the figures in the mid-1980s. But a higher oil price could be bad news for inflation, and lead to further interest rate increases around the world. As price reports are released almost every one has increased and that increase has been primarily attributable to oil.

The price of crude oil rose above $26 a barrel, the highest level in almost three years, amid expectations that rising demand will outstrip production and eliminate the global surplus. This was after a mild respite during October from the continuous price increases that have been seen earlier this year.

Many in the industry are hoping that a more reflective tone will emerge from the scheduled meeting in Riyadh of the Saudi Arabian, Venezuelan and Mexican oil ministers. The three countries - all of which are big suppliers to the United States, the world's largest oil market - were the architects of the original production restraint deal agreed in March 1998. The three, in common with other leading exporters, have already agreed to maintain the cuts until March 2000. The big question, but one that is unlikely to be answered full - at least publicly - is whether, and how, increased output could be engineered next year without triggering a steep price fall.

That explains why some in the cartel argue so vehemently for a continuation of the cuts, irrespective of the actual state of world oil stocks and the level of global oil demand. But no doubt some of OPEC's more thoughtful ministers may wish the speculative fires of the futures' market had not been stoked so persistently and publicly.

Indicator scoreboard
Europe
France
The September trade surplus was stronger than most analysts had forecast. Third quarter exports, boosted by a surge in July, were up 7.2 percent on the quarter and 4.5 percent higher on the year. Third quarter imports were up 2.7 percent on the quarter and 4.3 percent higher on the year. Roughly a third of the rise since May was due to higher energy costs, while stronger demand for semi-finished goods and autos account for the rest.

Germany
October wholesale prices in October were at the low end of expectations, falling 0.1 percent on the month.

After the temporary pause in September, the Ifo Institute's west German business sentiment index rose again in October, though at a slightly slower pace than expected. The October reading rose to 96.1 from an unrevised 95.4 in September, due solely to an improvement in business expectations. Sentiment on current conditions fell for the second month in a row. The October index level as the highest since last August.

Britain
October retail prices less mortgage interest payments (RPIX), inched up 0.1 percent on the month and 2.2 percent on the year. The increase was mainly due to higher motoring costs as both gasoline prices and vehicle insurance costs rose. The RPIX is the Bank of England's primary inflation gauge. The retail price index (RPI) rose 0.2 percent on the month and 1.2 percent on the year. Food prices fell 0.2 percent on the month and 1.6 percent when compared with last year as supermarket price wars continued to push down the prices of nonseasonal foods.

October retail sales volume growth exceeded expectations and reached its highest annual rate in nearly two years. Retail sales volumes rose by 0.5 percent on the month and by 4.7 percent on the year. This was the highest annual rate since January 1998. For the quarter, retail sales volumes rose by 1.2 percent on the quarter and by four percent on the same three months a year ago. Again, the annual rate was the highest since March 1998.

July-September average earnings rose 4.7 percent, easing from 4.9 percent in June to August, as the bonus effect reflected in the June data dropped out of the calculation. The result was closer to the 4.5 percent the Bank of England has said is compatible with achieving the inflation target.

Asia
Japan
September's industrial output on a seasonally adjusted basis was revised to a monthly fall of 0.6 percent. On an unadjusted basis, the index remained 2.8 percent higher than a year ago. For the July through September quarter, industrial production rose by 3.9 percent, which was the largest quarterly increase since the first quarter of 1976.

Americas
Canada
September manufacturers' shipments rose 0.8 percent, the seventh consecutive monthly increase, as shipments of petroleum, coal and paper products climbed in the month. Excluding the 0.5 percent decline in the autos, parts and accessories sector, shipments increased 1.2 percent in the month. There were gains in 17 of 22 manufacturing sectors, accounting for 82.7 percent of the total value of shipments. The value of unfilled orders rose for the fifth consecutive month, up 1.9 percent as unfilled orders in the motor vehicle and electrical and electronic parts industries rose 11.2 percent and 8.1 percent, respectively.

September's merchandise trade surplus narrowed to C$2.52 billion as exports dropped 3.2 percent and imports edged higher in the month. The trade gap and exports had hit record high levels in August. Exports fell 3.2 percent in September after a revised 3.5 percent gain in August, as exports in the auto industry plummeted 10.4 percent after hitting a record high the month before. Imports climbed 0.4 percent after August's 2.7 percent increase, primarily because of a strong increase in crude and fuel oil imports. Exports to the United States, Canada's largest market, decreased 3.7 percent. Imports from the United States were 0.2 percent higher in the month, leaving the trade gap at C$5.02 billion, down from August's record C$6.07 billion.

October's consumer price index edged up 0.1 percent. The increase is attributed to the 1.2 percent increase in energy prices. Excluding energy, the CPI remained unchanged from last month. When compared with last year, the consumer price index jumped 2.3 percent. While the increase continued to reflect the pattern of climbing energy prices that began in April, the rate of increase for the CPI slowed slightly from September's 2.6 percent year over year rise. Excluding energy prices, the CPI rose 1.5 percent. The increases in the energy index in September and October were the largest since early 1991.

Mexico
Third quarter gross domestic product soared 4.6 percent over the same period a year ago fueled by dynamic growth in the service sector among other factors. This pushes year-date growth up to 3.2 percent, bringing the government's goal of 3.4 percent for year-end into focus. Industrial production rose 4.3 percent in the third quarter with the manufacturing, utilities and construction increasing, 5.3 percent, 3.4 percent and 2.3 percent, respectively. Mining fell 3.1 percent. In the first and second quarter this year, the GDP rose 1.9 percent and 3.2 percent, respectively.

World Financial Markets

World Equity Markets
With the exception of the London FTSE, all of the major equity markets rose last week. Several of the indexes set new highs for the year. Others came close.


Selected World Stock Market Indexes
Index19-Nov1999
High
1999
Low
Week %
Change
Asia
AustraliaAll Ordinaries3076.703145.202804.802.21
JapanNikkei 22518570.8418570.8413232.701.71
Hong KongHang Seng15073.1015073.109076.336.23
S. KoreaKorea Composite993.111027.93498.422.46
SingaporeStraits Times2221.042222.451286.561.61
Europe
BritainFTSE 1006482.306598.805770.20-0.45
FranceCAC 5263.235263.233958.702.37
GermanyXETRA DAX5955.975955.974668.502.85
North America
United StatesDow11003.8911209.809120.702.18
CanadaTSE Composite 3007693.207693.206180.302.22
MexicoBolsa 6286.686286.683300.424.17

Asia
Both the Tokyo Nikkei and Hong Kong Heng Seng indexes closed the week at new highs. The South Korean composite nudged over 1000 before slipping back to close the week at 993. The Australian All Ordinaries and Singapore Straits indexes closed out the week just below their 1999 highs.

The Heng Seng index celebrated the United States/China trade agreement. The agreement, which paves the way for Chinese membership in the World Trade Organization, had been on the brink of failure and was saved only by last second concessions. China still has to hammer out agreements with the European Union, Canada and others before membership formally will be considered by the WTO. China will not be joining the WTO before the organization's summit meeting in Seattle at the end of the month.

Europe
Both the German DAX and the French CAC indexes closed the week at yearly highs. Only the FTSE closed a shade lower on the week. The DAX gained 165 points on the week or 2.85 percent and the CAC, 121 points or 2.37 percent.

The FTSE sank 29 points or 0.45 percent. Instead of assaulting record peaks, the FTSE suffered its heaviest one day points loss in a month on Friday. The index was brought down by profit taking and the monthly expiry of the FTSE 100 option series along with an opening weakness on Wall Street. In addition, the FTSE was roiled by the proposed hostile takeover offer of Germany's Mannesmann by Britain's Vodafone, fueling speculation of more consolidation in the telecommunications sector.

Currencies
Asia
Yen
The dollar held recent gains against the yen, as expectations of a continued U.S. stock rally boosted the demand for dollars to buy equities. The yen closed trading this week at 106.29 yen to the dollar, down from 105.21 in New York. Generally, when the yen falls in value (that is, more yen to the dollar), the Nikkei rises because it improves the profit picture for Japanese exporters.

Europe
Euro
The euro sank to its lowest level in four months. Rising U.S. stocks and a German Ifo business confidence report hurt the currency. The report discouraged investors who hoped to see stronger signs of European economic growth. The euro fell to $1.0266 per euro from $1.0416, the lowest level for the currency since July 19. The euro closed the week at $1.0306. Dollar gains have accompanied climbing stocks since October 15, when U.S. stock market indexes fell to six month lows. The currency has risen 4.5 percent against the euro since then.

Sterling
Sterling is expected to maintain its strength amid the markets' expectation that the Bank of England will raise interest rates again as economic growth continues to accelerate. Expectations for higher rates were reinforced last week when economic reports showed a leap in October retail sales, the unemployment rate at a 19 year low and a bigger than expected majority of the Bank of England's rate committee in favor of a rate increase on November 4th. Higher rates may draw investors to pounds as the return on sterling denominated deposits also increases.

Why U.S. investors should care...
With interest rate concerns behind them, the markets should be able to concentrate on earnings and other traditional end of year trading issues. The United States-China trade agreement will make many new investment and market opportunities in China available to U.S. companies.

Looking Ahead

Central Bank Activities
Nov 26JapanBank of Japan Monetary Policy Committee Meeting


The following indicators will be released this week...

Europe
Nov 22ItalyRetail Sales (September)
EMUM3 (October)
Nov 23FranceIndustrial Production (September)
Consumer Spending (October)
ItalyNon-EU Trade Balance (October)
World Trade Balance (September)
Nov 24GermanyConsumer Price Index (November)
Nov 25EMUIndustrial Production (September)
GermanyProducer Prices (October)
Import/Export Prices (October)
Nov 26Current Account Balance ((September)
ItalyPreliminary Consumer Price Index (November)
Asia
Nov 25JapanRetail Sales (October)
Wholesale Sales (October)
Nov 26JapanTrade Balance (October)
Consumer Price Index (October)
Americas
Nov 26CanadaIndustrial Product Price Index (October)
Raw Material Price Index (October)

Release dates are subject to change.
For U.S. data releases, see this week's Simply Economics.